Lesson 9: One practice, six frameworks
You will be able to: recognize what each of six frameworks is, when it applies, and how ordinary engineering practice produces the evidence each one needs.
About 6 min
The practices from the first eight lessons (scope, access, change, data handling, evidence, incident response, and AI governance) are the same no matter which framework applies. What differs is why a framework applies, who checks it, and which details it emphasizes.
| Framework | What it is | Who checks |
|---|---|---|
| SOC 2 | Attestation examination and report, not a certification | A licensed, independent CPA firm, performing the examination under AICPA attestation standards. |
| ISO 27001 | International standard for an information security management system (ISMS), certifiable | Certification bodies, through an initial certification audit and periodic surveillance audits. |
| ISO 42001 | International standard for an AI management system (AIMS), certifiable | Certification bodies, through certification and surveillance audits. |
| HIPAA | U.S. federal law and regulations (45 CFR Parts 160 and 164) | Enforced by the HHS Office for Civil Rights; state attorneys general can also bring actions. |
| GDPR | European Union regulation | National supervisory authorities, coordinated through the European Data Protection Board. |
| CMMC | U.S. Department of Defense contract program (32 CFR Part 170; DFARS 252.204-7021) | Depending on the level the contract specifies: a self-assessment, an assessment by an authorized third-party organization (C3PAO), or a government assessment by DIBCAC. |
Scenario 1 of 6: SOC 2: the service auditor’s request
During Brightwell’s SOC 2 Type 2 examination for 1 January – 31 December 2025, the service auditor asks for evidence that production changes followed the change process during the period.
Which evidence best shows that change control operated during the period?
Scenario 2 of 6: ISO/IEC 27001: closing the loop on a risk
Brightwell’s ISMS risk register lists: “Credentials leaked through source code.” You own the treatment.
What completes the management-system loop for this risk?
Scenario 3 of 6: ISO/IEC 42001: whose certificate is it?
Brightwell is pursuing ISO/IEC 42001 certification, and the support reply assistant is in scope. Its model vendor holds its own ISO/IEC 42001 certificate.
What does your team need to contribute?
Scenario 4 of 6: HIPAA: a new observability vendor
Brightwell serves clinics that are HIPAA covered entities, and has signed business associate agreements with them. An engineer wants to send API request logs, which include appointment notes, to a new observability vendor for a 30-day trial.
What should happen before any logs are sent?
Scenario 5 of 6: GDPR: a field “in case we need it”
Brightwell’s signup form for patients in the EU asks for date of birth. The product team says it is “useful to have in case we need it later.”
What should you do?
Scenario 6 of 6: CMMC: CUI and a new tool
Ardent Systems (a fictional company) builds software for a defense prime contractor. Its subcontract includes DFARS 252.204-7012 and a CMMC Level 2 requirement. Engineering drawings marked CUI are stored in Ardent’s assessed environment. A developer wants to paste excerpts into a commercial AI assistant to speed up their work.
What is the right call?
Key points
- SOC 2 is an attestation report; Type 2 tests operation over a period.
- ISO/IEC 27001 and 42001 are certifiable management systems: assess, treat, measure, correct.
- HIPAA applies to covered entities and business associates; vendors handling ePHI need a BAA, encrypted or not.
- GDPR is about personal data and people’s rights: purpose, minimisation, retention, accountability.
- CMMC scope follows CUI and FCI; keep that information inside the assessed boundary.